Home  >  NEWS  >  Plastic Cosmetic Tubes vs. PCR Squeeze Tubes: Which Is the Better Choice for Your Brand?

Plastic Cosmetic Tubes vs. PCR Squeeze Tubes: Which Is the Better Choice for Your Brand?

2024-12-29

As consumers become more environmentally conscious, brands across industries are facing increasing pressure to reconsider their packaging options. In the beauty and cosmetics sector, packaging plays a pivotal role, not only in the protection and preservation of products but also in shaping brand identity. One of the key debates among beauty brands is whether to continue using traditional plastic cosmetic tubes or transition to PCR squeeze tubes (Post-Consumer Recycled tubes).

Both types of tubes have their advantages, but when it comes to sustainability, cost, and consumer perception, the choice isn't always clear-cut.


pcr squeeeze tubes                
pcr squeeze tubes


plastic tube                
virgin plastic cosmetic tube

1. Material Composition: Virgin Plastic vs. Recycled Plastic

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: These tubes are typically made from virgin plastics, meaning they are produced from new, petroleum-based materials. Common plastic types include LDPE (Low-Density Polyethylene) and HDPE (High-Density Polyethylene), both of which offer excellent flexibility, durability, and barrier protection for the contents inside.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: In contrast, PCR squeeze tubes are made from post-consumer recycled plastic—plastic that has been used by consumers and then recycled and repurposed. This helps reduce the need for new plastic production and supports a circular economy, making them an eco-friendly alternative.

2. Environmental Impact: Reducing Plastic Waste

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: While virgin plastic tubes are highly durable and functional, they come with a significant environmental cost. Virgin plastics are made from fossil fuels, contributing to resource depletion and environmental degradation. Additionally, many plastic tubes are not recyclable, or they are difficult to recycle due to mixed materials or coatings.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: PCR tubes have a clear sustainability advantage. By using recycled plastic, they help reduce the demand for virgin materials and decrease plastic waste. When consumers choose products with PCR packaging, they are directly contributing to reducing plastic pollution. However, the recycling process isn't perfect, and the quality of recycled plastics may degrade over time, making it difficult to reuse the material for multiple product cycles.

3. Cost Considerations: Affordability vs. Sustainability

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: Traditional plastic tubes are generally less expensive to manufacture. Since they are made from new materials, they don’t require the extra costs associated with cleaning, sorting, and processing recycled plastics. For brands looking to minimize production costs, virgin plastic tubes remain a cost-effective choice.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: On the other hand, PCR squeeze tubes often come with a slightly higher production cost due to the extra steps involved in the recycling process. However, as demand for eco-friendly packaging rises and recycling technology improves, the price gap between virgin plastic and PCR materials is narrowing. Over time, the increased consumer demand for sustainable products may make PCR packaging a more economically viable option.

4. Durability and Functionality: How Well Do They Protect Products?

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: Virgin plastic tubes are known for their excellent durability and flexibility, which makes them ideal for products that need to be dispensed easily and safely, such as creams, lotions, and serums. These tubes are resistant to crushing, can be sealed tightly to protect contents, and typically offer superior barrier properties to prevent contamination from air, light, and bacteria.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: While PCR tubes are still functional, they may not be as durable or flexible as virgin plastic tubes. Because recycled plastic can sometimes be more brittle, PCR tubes may not offer the same high level of protection for sensitive formulations. However, recent advancements in recycling technologies have led to improvements in PCR tube quality, making them more competitive in terms of functionality.

5. Aesthetics and Brand Perception: The Eco-Friendly Factor

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: Virgin plastic tubes are highly customizable, offering a wide range of finishes, from matte to glossy, and vibrant colors, which can make them visually striking on store shelves. These tubes also allow for intricate branding, helping brands create a premium and high-end aesthetic. However, with growing concerns about plastic pollution, brands using virgin plastic packaging may face backlash from eco-conscious consumers.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: PCR tubes may have a more matte or textured finish, and their appearance may not be as polished as virgin plastic tubes. However, for brands focused on sustainability, the use of PCR packaging can be a powerful statement. Eco-conscious consumers are often willing to trade a glossy finish for a more responsible, planet-friendly product. Highlighting the recycled nature of the packaging can resonate with a growing demographic that values sustainability over luxury aesthetics.

6. Consumer Trends: The Demand for Sustainable Packaging

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: As sustainability becomes an increasingly important factor for consumers, traditional plastic packaging is under scrutiny. Brands that continue to use virgin plastic packaging may risk alienating eco-conscious shoppers who prefer brands that prioritize environmental responsibility.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: PCR tubes appeal to eco-conscious consumers who prioritize sustainable packaging and ethical production practices. For beauty brands that want to align themselves with green initiatives, switching to PCR packaging can be an effective way to demonstrate their commitment to sustainability. Research shows that many consumers are willing to pay a premium for products that feature environmentally friendly packaging.

7. Brand Opportunities: How to Position Your Brand with PCR Tubes

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes: Brands that use virgin plastic may need to invest in additional sustainability initiatives, such as offering a recycling program, using recyclable materials, or developing refillable packaging options, in order to improve their environmental image.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes: Brands that choose PCR packaging can use it as a strong marketing tool. By promoting the use of recycled materials, brands can tap into the growing demand for sustainable products. Marketers can highlight the eco-friendly nature of their packaging, tapping into a niche market that values transparency and sustainability.

Conclusion: Which Is Right for Your Brand?

The decision between plastic cosmetic tubes and PCR squeeze tubes ultimately depends on your brand’s values, target audience, and product requirements.

  • Plastic Cosmetic Tubes remain a strong choice for brands that prioritize cost-efficiency and design flexibility. They offer excellent durability and protection for cosmetic products, but they come with an environmental cost.

  • PCR Squeeze Tubes, on the other hand, are a more sustainable alternative that appeals to environmentally-conscious consumers. While they may carry a slightly higher production cost, PCR tubes offer brands a chance to align with eco-friendly values and reduce their environmental footprint.

For brands aiming to reduce waste and support a circular economy, PCR squeeze tubes provide a solid solution. As sustainability becomes more important to consumers, switching to recycled packaging is not only good for the planet but also for your brand's reputation.


Top 6 PCR and Virgin Plastic Squeeze Tube Manufacturers: A Guide to Quality and Sustainability

#1 Lisson Packaging

  • Over 25 years of experience

  • Offers both PCR and virgin plastic tubes

  • Wide product range, including tubes, bottles, and jars.


#2 Amcor

  • Known for sustainable packaging solutions

  • Provides both PCR and virgin plastic squeeze tubes.


#3 Albea

  • Specializes in eco-friendly packaging

  • Offers PCR tubes with up to 100% recycled content.


#4 Essel Propack

  • Leading in laminated tubes

  • Offers a variety of PCR and virgin plastic squeeze tubes.


#5 M&H Plastics

  • Provides custom packaging

  • Offers PCR and virgin plastic squeeze tubes.


#6 Quadpack

  • Focuses on sustainable beauty packaging

  • Offers both PCR and virgin plastic squeeze tubes.


Chat Online
Chat Online
Leave Your Message inputting...
Dear friend, thank you for your message. Could you please offer us your email? We will answer your questions as soon as possible. Thank you! ^_^